Best Roasting Pan for the Perfect Thanksgiving Turkey

The time is coming when roasting pans all over the nation will be brought out to roast Thanksgiving turkey to golden perfection. But what really makes the best roasting pan for the job?

If this is your first time hosting Thanksgiving dinner, finding a good roasting pan plus knowing how to thaw a turkey can be a little overwhelming. The experts at GFY Appliance Repair searched high and low to find the perfect turkey roasting pan for your Thanksgiving feast.

Best Roasting Pan for Thanksgiving Turkey 2020

When it comes to a great roasting pan, your top choice should be one that best fits your needs. That’s why our list of the best roasting pan 2020 covers all categories from the best covered roasting pans to the best economical choice.

Best Overall Roasting Pan:
Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 16-inch Rectangular Roaster

Our pick for the best roasting pan overall checks off every box. It has Cuisinart’s superior construction with a roasting rack and riveted handles, allowing you to handle it with ease even when roasting large cuts of meat.

It’s dishwasher safe and, best of all, its relatively low price point makes it a great deal for such a high-quality pan.

  • Features: excellent heat transfer with solid stainless steel construction, durability
  • Price: $43.78
  • Buy on Amazon
best roasting pan
Image Credit: Amazon

Best Stainless Steel Roasting Pan:
Calphalon Contemporary 16-inch Stainless Steel Roasting Pan

You need a roasting pan that’ll to brown to perfection and this roaster from Calphalon does just that. It’s tri-ply construction makes for excellent heat conduction and enables the pan to go from oven to stovetop with ease.

  • Features: u-shaped roasting rack, roomy stainless steel handles, long-lasting reliability
  • Price: $139. 99
  • Buy on Amazon
best roasting pan 2019
Image Credit: Amazon

Best High-End Roasting Pan:
All-Clad Stainless Steel Large 16-inch Roaster

If you are a frequent roaster or have a wider budget, the All-Clad roasting pan with rack is one of our top choices. The roaster’s high sides help contain juices and the v-shaped roasting rack can keep even large cuts of meat from touching the pan.

Coupled with the pan’s excellent stainless steel construction, you’ll be able to brown to perfection for years to come.

  • Features: hallmark All-Clad construction, long-lasting performance
  • Price: $179.99
  • Buy on Amazon
best stainless steel roasting pan
Image Credit: Amazon

Best Roasting Pan on a Budget:
Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick Roasting Pan

When your budget is tight but you still need a roaster that can do the job done right, this pan by Wilton is our best roasting pan for the budget-conscious.

This is a big 17-inch pan that can accommodate anything from a 25lb turkey to a large prime rib. Its non-stick coating makes cleanup a breeze and you can’t beat the price for stainless steel construction.

  • Features: can accommodate large cuts of meat, easy cleanup, long-lasting stainless steel
  • Price: $15.99
  • Buy on Amazon
turkey roasting pan
Image Credit: Amazon

Best Covered Roasting Pan:
Granite Ware 19-inch Covered Oval Roaster

Our choice for the best roasting pan with lid goes to Granite Ware’s porcelain-coated roaster. The coating provides non-stick capabilities without the use of chemicals, while the steel core evenly distributes heat.

The lid banishes the use of pesky tin foil and helps control browning, speeds up cooking, and ensures juicy, flavorful meat.

  • Features: porcelain and steel construction for easy cleanup, superior heat distribution, perfect for smaller poultry up to 20lbs
  • Price: $45.45
  • Buy on Amazon
best roasting pan with lid
Image Credit: Amazon


We hope our run-down of roasters helps you decide on the best roasting pan for your Thanksgiving turkey. And if holiday roasting proves to be too much for your oven, call GFY Appliance Repair to schedule an oven repair!

brad edwards GFY Appliance Service

Brad Edwards, Owner

10% off
appliance repair

Subscribe to our newsletter…

We share maintenance tips, home hacks, seasonal recipes, appliance recall alerts, and more.

Browse by topic

New & noteworthy

leave it to the pros